Wednesday, June 3, 2009
micro-lending for a Mutual activity? a progressive spin on Integrity #7
This past weekend my stake had a YW conference, themed on small things we can do to make a difference in the world. One of the speakers happened to talk about microlending and the work of Mohammed Yunus and the Grameen Bank. Then (obviously not by coincidence), a couple of days later I got this email from Joanne, who lives in the MidWest. She writes:
One of the strengths of the YW Personal Progress (PP) program is its flexibility. Participants can literally write their own curriculum. From what I understand, for all its virtues, the Boy Scout program is not so flexible. So here I am, YW second counselor, trying to help the young women take advantage of that freedom. I tell them, "Put the personal in Personal Progress!" But it's hard for them to think outside the box and consider anything other than the dominant reading of the value experiences and projects. And it's hard for me to pitch something unusual; until I read Integrity #7 for the 10th time.
Integrity #7 invites us to consider the forces that weaken the family and home. It's easy to make a list of negative trends. One problem that is often left off this list is economic poverty. Maybe poverty is forgotten because we don't want to criticize wealth or capitalism. Or maybe poverty gets forgotten because we prefer to focus on individual sins rather than societal or institutional problems. Nevertheless, poverty threatens families throughout the world, and poverty has real causes that responsible, moral youth should be aware of.
So, in the spirit of Integrity #7, I would like to introduce fair trade and micro-lending during an upcoming Mutual activity. I want to take the girls to a nearby fair trade shop (think Ten Thousand Villages) and have the manager explain the moral dimensions of poverty and responsible buying. The girls could hold in their 1st world hands some cool handmade items from around the world, and hopefully feel a physical connection to their struggling sisters and brothers. They can shop and become educated at the same time. The manager may prepare a small ethnic snack. Afterward, we do a pseudo-fast offering: we take the budget money we would have spent on refreshments (plus spare change) and invest it in a micro-loan. Over the months and years, we monitor the health of the business we sponsored. To increase the impact of the micro-loan, we pool our money with money from young women from anywhere in the church.
I think the benefits are obvious: cultivating a social conscience, seeing the power of small sacrifices, feeling a connection with like-minded young women. Some potential problems I foresee: Does this activity sound paternalistic or elitist or political? Does it instill guilt in young women who can only afford to buy made-in-China stuff? We don't do fundraisers anymore, but does this sound like a fundraiser? (It's not!)
So I have two questions:
1) How many of you would like to try this activity and contribute to an LDS YW micro-lending account, shared by young women across the church? (I'm shooting for August, but anyone could join at any time, I believe.)
2) How have you personalized PP in creative or progressive ways?
Labels:
activities,
guest posts,
money,
Personal Progress,
service
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)






7 comments:
I think the microlending thing is a great idea. I love the idea of thematically connecting it to fast offerings by using the money you would have spent on refreshments. This is a great way for the YW to feel like they're doing something to help with a huge paralyzing problem.
The fair-trade aspect of the activity concerns me a bit. I know your heart is in the right place, but it does strike me as being a bit political. (There was a big controversy at my university several years ago about fair-trade coffee. It was a multi-faceted problem with good, moral people on all sides of the issue.) It has the potential to be needlessly divisive. If it's something that's important to you, perhaps you can make yourself available to answer any questions they have on their own time (making it clear that you're speaking as an individual and not as a church leader).
I love that you're personalizing the personal progress program. It didn't feel relevant to me when I was in YW because I came from a different background than everyone else, and we all did the same stuff.
I bumped into this a while ago
http://www.beadforlife.org/index.html
It is an organization that supports women in Uganda; they make jewelry and people here in the states host a party to sell that jewelry and then you send the money and anything you didn't sell back.
It sounds like a nice way to learn about people and help a bit. I think it would be pretty easy for a YW group to host this kind of a party, invite the RS, make the regional food (they provide recipes) and learn about the women involved (they send an informational DVD).
I have not tried it, but am thinking about hosting such a party.
I like the micro-lending idea. Am indifferent on the free-trade store idea.
Thanks for the great feedback. I needed some perspective. Other ideas:
-Cooking -- think about diabetic, ethnic, vegetarian, etc.
-"Home arts skill" -- home repairs and minor redecorating, basic car stuff
--Divine Nature #7 -- peace on an interpersonal level, but you could touch on social peace and how our 19th century Mormon foremothers participated in peace movements
-Conference talks -- you can always look up talks by Jack-Okazaki-Clyde
-Individual Worth #5 pedigree chart -- On the Exponent II blog, I once read about a special girls-only pedigree chart that Sister Hinckley used.
I like the fair-trade store. The one in my town has a totally different atmosphere than a regular store. With a great percentage of the items made from recycled materials.. old Coke cans, newspaper, etc...
I think the visually and the tactile experience of being in the store would create an experience and "teach" the concept in a way that just watching a video or describing the micro-loan concept within the confines of the church building would not.
Just my two cents.. go to the store.
I love the idea and we may do it in our ward too.
Question - is there one micro-loan program you are going with? Kiva? It would be extra cool to donate with other YW groups.
When I was a YW (just a few years ago), my family did nearly all shopping at Wal-Mart. I felt terrible about it, at first because other teens teased me about my wal-mart clothes, but as I got older and learned more about wal-mart I felt terrible about their practices as well. The thing is, though, as a teen I had no control over where my parents shopped. Even when I got my first job and started doing a lot of my own shopping, most of the things we used as a family still came from wal-mart.
I would have enjoyed an activity like this, but it would have made me feel guilty, not empowered. Maybe you could include a caveat that the girls aren't responsible for where anyone else (including family) spends money?
Ariel -- I hear you. If we go to the shop, I'll make sure the girls get the right message. Heck, I still buy stuff at Wal-Mart. But being aware is a first step.
twinmomnc -- I was thinking of Kiva. Do you want to collaborate? We could let the girls help choose the borrower,etc. Please email me at juddandjoanne (at) juno (dot) com. Even if there is only one young woman (or leader) outside of our Indiana ward who wants to do this goal for herself, I would love to be able to say that we are working with young women outside our ward who share similar values. Thanks!
This is a great idea! I am SO disappointed that I'm no longer in YW so I could do this too! I love microloans, Heifer International, all those programs. Another point: microloans almost exclusively benefit women and their families, which also makes it a great YW activity.
I think the fair-trade angle is good, but I would suggest that you just don't cram it down their throats. I agree that awareness is the first step, and that's what you are trying to give them. That should keep any poverty-induced guilt at bay.
Post a Comment